Note: the following list is not listed in any particular order, and Window Managers are not included.
1. GNOME Shell
For (New) Laptop Users
For users of new laptops, I would recommend GNOME. One thing is for sure: Gnome is not the easiest to use straightaway. Its design deviates from the usual desktop design, and you need extensions to enable some features that should be there from the start. However, the way GNOME is constructed with Wayland being the default display server protocol means that it has great built-in touchpad gesture support, and its extensions enable you to extend its functionality. The good thing is, you can easily transform GNOME into something tailor-made for you within minutes! With a large suite of extensions, this desktop environment is noticeably heavier on system resources, so this is a recommendation for those users that have a mid-range laptop.
For Workstation Users
I recommend GNOME for workstations as well, particularly Pop! OS with GNOME. Pop! OS is such a great choice for workstation users because of the ease of installation on PCs with Nvidia GPUs. There’s a separate ISO file that already contains the proprietary Nvidia drivers, making it a total piece of cake to work with. It’s also such a polished workstation distro that’s so tightly integrated with GNOME that the whole package is simple to use. Just keep in mind that at any point in the near future, Pop!_OS may move onto its home-brew desktop environment called COSMIC. While similar to GNOME, the differences are sufficient that you may have to make several adjustments to settle in with the new environment if you switch over. Like most other distros, Pop!_OS will have GNOME as a package just in case you really don’t like COSMIC once the switch happens.
2. KDE Plasma
If you’re the kind of person who likes to constantly tinker and change the way your OS experience flows, Plasma is absolutely for you. In our review, we called it the “Swiss army knife” of DEs. You can change every aspect of Plasma, meaning you can make it look almost exactly like macOS or Windows if that’s something you’d like to do. There are endless customizations you can do to Plasma, which means that if you’re willing to put in the work, you can really make it work for any workflow. If you want to look at how much you can change Plasma, have a look at some of the modifications made by Garuda Linux.
3. Cinnamon / Pantheon
If you’re coming from either Windows or macOS, I would highly recommend Cinnamon or Pantheon, respectively. Cinnamon is a kind of gateway DE: it has many customization options, but it’s also just exactly what you’d expect coming from Windows. It feels much like Windows 7 in its workflow, and it’s even very gentle on system resources, which makes it an ideal fit for your relatively old machine that doesn’t run Windows very well anymore. Things will fly once you install Cinnamon. Pantheon is quite like macOS. If you’re coming to Linux from macOS, I would highly suggest that you try out elementaryOS, which is home to the most natural and integrated experiences with Pantheon in the community. The workflow is exactly the same as macOS, and there are more touchpad gestures and features that are set to make Pantheon work even more like macOS. Pantheon is also one of the easiest experiences for HiDPI displays, which makes total sense for a DE designed to swap in for macOS. It will automatically detect the resolution of your display and make things look appropriately-sized for your monitor. You will get the best Pantheon experience from elementaryOS. Alternatively, in Ubuntu and Debian-based systems, you can install elementary-desktop to get Pantheon. If you want to install this in Arch, the process is a bit complicated but you can check the Arch Wiki for guidance.
4. XFCE
If you have an older or less powerful machine, particularly an old netbook, XFCE would be a great choice. It’s incredibly lightweight when pared down and strikes the balance between extremely lightweight DEs like LXDE or LXQt and full-fat DEs like KDE and GNOME. Its resource usage is very low, but there are still many options for customization and configuration. One of the cleanest and easy-to-use implementations of XFCE is in Xubuntu, with a great icon theme and high-quality menus.
5. Budgie
If you want a highly-customizable desktop experience like KDE Plasma offers, but without the high learning curve, Budgie provides an excellent canvas for you. Using a lot of GNOME’s suite of applications, users of the eponymous environment or Cinnamon will find Budgie very familiar, though it has a more modern look than the latter.
6. Deepin
If you want a complete out-of-the-box experience, Deepin offers a unique, sleek visual style that was tailor-made for the Chinese market. Although it’s lacking in customization options, many of its fans point out that the styling and workflow is already more than satisfying as-is. Deepin is meant to be used with its namesake distro, but that shouldn’t stop you from installing it in your favorite! Almost every other distro contains a Deepin desktop package. Image credit: Ian Allen on Wikimedia Commons This happens, for example, when you install Budgie over Cinnamon in Linux Mint. Since they use the same files for styling and visuals, a visual change in one will affect the other. Remember to make a proper backup of your system using applications like Timeshift or rsync before installing a new desktop environment so you can reverse the changes if you experience a catastrophe. KDE’s developers diverged their desktop away from GNOME several years ago and have since worked on providing a unified experience through one platform. Cinnamon, instead of completely abandoning the GNOME suite, adapted to use some of it (Gedit, GNOME Terminal, GNOME System Monitor, etc.) while providing an entirely different visual experience. Because of this, Cinnamon’s interface might not be entirely uniform as some of the GNOME applications it uses don’t conform completely with the visual styling. KDE applications, on the other hand, adopt the universal system theme seamlessly, providing a more uniform experience.
